Do Gutters have to be Removed When Replacing a Roof?

So, you’re staring down the barrel of a $6,000 to $15,000 bill to swap out your roof. Ouch, right? You’d want every bit of that job done just right. Now, here’s a curveball – should those gutters take a hike before the new shingles come in? Well, it’s not a one-size-fits-all answer, but yeah, in a lot of cases, waving goodbye to your old gutters first is the way to go.

But wait, there’s more. “Will this cost me an arm and a leg?” you wonder. Here’s the scoop: some contractors might tack on a bit extra for the hustle of removing and then putting back your gutters. And if they’re swapping them for fresh ones? Expect the price tag to inch up even more. My advice? Get all those nitty-gritty details ironed out before you sign on the dotted line. Trust me, you don’t want a surprise $2,000 making your wallet weep when all’s said and done.

Key Takeaway

In most cases, the gutters do not need to be removed when replacing a roof. However, some roofing contractors will not offer a warranty unless roofing components such as gutters are not replaced.

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.

Why Do Gutters have to be Removed When Replacing a Roof?

I’ve gotta say, there’s something almost magical about discovering your house is built in a way that saves you a headache or two. Take gutters and roofs, for instance. I remember when we were gearing up to replace our roof, dreading the thought of having to deal with the gutters. Imagine my surprise when the contractor told us, “No need to worry about those gutters; they’re attached to the fascia board, not the roof.”

Honestly, it felt like winning a small lottery. Because the gutters weren’t directly tied to the roof, the crew could work their magic without any interference. It’s these little construction quirks that can make a big difference. So, if your gutters are giving the roof space, consider yourself lucky. It’s a small victory, but hey, I’ll take it.

Because of their home’s construction, some people don’t have to remove their gutters before replacing their roof. They can get away with this because the gutters connect to a fascia board instead of the roof. Since there’s not a direct connection between the roof and the gutters, roofers can put on the new roof without the gutter system getting in the way.

What Are Fascia Boards and How Do I Know If My House Has Them?

Ever find yourself scratching your head, wondering what on earth fascia boards are? Yeah, me too. I mean, it’s not like we’re all climbing up our roofs with a cup of coffee to enjoy the view, right? Fascia boards might sound fancy, but they’re pretty much the unsung heroes holding your gutters in place. Made from wood or this stuff called uPVC, they’re like the sleek suit your house wears around its edges, giving it that neat, polished look.

So, you’ve moved into your dream home, or maybe you’re living under a roof so tall it could touch the clouds, and you’re curious about these fascia boards. Here’s a tip: grab a ladder (and maybe a buddy for safety) to take a peek. If there’s a strip sitting snug between your gutters and your roof, bingo, that’s your fascia board.

But hey, don’t sweat it if heights aren’t your thing. The next time a roofer swings by to chat about your roof, they can check it out for you. Saves you the trouble, and you get to keep both feet firmly on the ground. Trust me, it’s a win-win.

The Benefits of Removing Gutters Before Replacing Your Roof

As a homeowner, let’s be real: shelling out a chunk of change for a new roof isn’t exactly my idea of a fun time. But, it’s one of those necessary evils to keep our homes snug and dry. With that kind of investment on the line, you bet I want the contractor to knock it out of the park.

And let’s not even start on the gutters. The thought of forking over another $3,000 because I didn’t think to protect them? No, thank you. Before we go ripping off shingles like there’s no tomorrow, making sure those gutters are safe and sound is key.

Here’s a table that outlines the average costs of gutters for different sized homes. Note that these figures are estimates and actual costs may vary based on material choices, geographic location, and specific contractor rates.

Home SizeEstimated Gutter Cost
Small Home (Up to 1,500 sq ft)$1,000 – $2,500
Medium Home (1,500 – 2,500 sq ft)$2,500 – $4,000
Large Home (Over 2,500 sq ft)$4,000 – $6,000+
These costs can be impacted by several factors including the type of material chosen for the gutters (aluminum, copper, steel, etc.), the complexity of the installation, and whether or not old gutters need to be removed and disposed of. Always consult with a professional to get an accurate quotation for your home.

Now, you might be wondering why we’d even consider removing gutters before tackling the roof. Well, it’s not just about avoiding unexpected expenses; it’s about safeguarding the backbone of our home’s water drainage system. Stick around, and I’ll walk you through why this move is more savvy than it might seem at first glance.

You Could Find Damage Hiding Behind the Gutters

Peeling away those gutters isn’t just about making the job easier for your roofing crew; it’s like opening a secret door to what’s been hiding beneath. You see, once those gutters are out of the picture, you get a clear shot at spotting any sneaky damage lurking around both your roof and gutter system. It’s like detective work—without the magnifying glass.

Now, imagine it’s fall. Those two giant oak trees next to your house have been dropping leaves like nobody’s business, and yep, your gutters are now their favorite hangout spot. If you skip on cleaning and detaching those gutters before the big roof redo, you’re basically walking blind into potential trouble. Hidden damages? They’ll stay hidden, whispering future headaches and wallet woes. And let’s not forget, damaged gutters are a fast track to even more roof drama. Keeping those gutters in tip-top shape isn’t just smart; it’s essential.

It’s Safer for the Roofers to Work Without the Gutters

Although you should always hire a contractor with adequate insurance, replacing a roof without taking off the gutters is a bit riskier. Attempting to replace a roof with dirty or damaged gutters is like walking on a balance beam. It’s easy to fall off, and the job takes longer. This is also true when you get a roof over existing roof.

Many contractors prefer to remove gutters for this reason, especially if you haven’t cleaned them for a while. The only caveat to this is if you have fascia boards, as mentioned earlier. And if your gutters are dirty, then there’s a high chance that your roof is also messy, making the job even more hazardous for the roofers.

It Might Be Time to Replace the Gutters, too

If you’re diving into the deep end with a roof replacement, it’s worth asking: Why not swap out the gutters while we’re at it? Now, if your gutters are still shiny and new, mixing them into the renovation cocktail might not make sense. But, if they’re on the older side, bundling the two projects could be a savvy move for your budget.

Getting a pro to give your gutters the once-over now and then is like having a guardian angel for your home’s drainage system. They can spot trouble before it starts throwing a wrench in your peace of mind. Wondering when it’s time to wave goodbye to your current gutters? Keep an eye out for these red flags:

  • You see nails lying around the perimeter of your home
  • There are visible cracks in the gutters
  • The gutters are sagging or starting to separate from your roof
  • You notice water leaking
  • The gutters are starting to rust

Replacing Your Roof Could Inadvertently Damage Your Gutters

Having a crew up on your roof is a bit like hosting a dance party up there—there’s a lot going on, and occasionally, someone might step where they shouldn’t. Your gutters, those silent guardians of your home, could end up being the unwitting dance floor. Between the hustle and bustle, they might catch more than just rainwater. Roof debris could turn them into an impromptu storage bin for all sorts of stuff, including leaves and dirt, potentially leaving behind scratches or dents.

And let’s talk about nails. Those tiny metal critters are essential for the job, but they’re also masters of escape. A few might decide to take a dive into your gutters, and unlike those stray shingles that barely make a dent, these little guys can mean serious business. A punctured gutter is no joke—it’s like opening the door to leak city, population: your house. Damaged gutters don’t just stand by; they can bite back, putting your shiny new roof at risk. So, when you’re investing in a roof makeover, the last thing you want is to see your efforts (and dollars) go down the drain because of gutter drama.

Gutter Removal May Already Be Included in the Price of the Roofing Job

Here’s a little insider tip that might save you some hassle and potentially some cash: many roofing companies come with a squad skilled in both roof and gutter work. Due to how intertwined these tasks can be, some geniuses out there decided, “Hey, let’s just bundle this service.” So, when you’re getting your roof done, they might offer to handle your gutters—removing and reinstalling them—as part of the whole shebang. Sometimes, this extra care doesn’t even bump up your bill; it’s just part of the package. Why pass up on a deal like that? It’s a straightforward way to dodge any potential mishaps that could harm your gutters or, worse, your newly minted roof.

And here’s the kicker: if your gutters are showing their age or wear and tear, this is your moment to shine. Chat with your contractor about rolling a gutter upgrade into your roofing project. Merging these two jobs can be easier on your schedule and kinder to your wallet than hunting down another contractor later on. Plus, it’s one less thing to worry about, and who doesn’t love ticking two big items off their home maintenance list with one stroke?

See Also: Do You Actually Need Gutters on Your Home

Removing the Gutters Beforehand is an Industry Best Practice

Let’s cut to the chase: taking gutters down before launching into a roof replacement isn’t just some fancy procedure—it’s the gold standard in the roofing biz. This move is all about safeguarding your home’s backbone and ensuring those hardworking roofers stay safe up there. When the gutters come off, it’s like putting on x-ray glasses; suddenly, any lurking damage that could spell trouble down the line becomes crystal clear.

So, unless your gutters are living a separate life from your roof (which is rare), getting your contractor to do a pre-roof replacement gutter removal should be part of your game plan. It’s a simple step that packs a punch in protecting your home and making the whole process smoother.

Rick Anderson

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *